Saturday, 6 April 2013

Positive Impact vs. Negative Impact

Firstly, my position on this topic is for. Yes, youth who volunteer gain many positive results from their experiences, and so do those on the receiving end of their work.



I've been researching this topic over the past two days, and have ascertained that there can also be negative effects of youth volunteering. I can therefore create a balanced argument for this topic.

Here are some of the links I have come across so far:


Positive impact highlighted

Child Trends: "Teens As Volunteers"

Ministry of Youth Development: "The Impact of Youth Work for Young People"

Student Volunteer Army: "History"

NZ Herald: "Social entrepreneurship: Solution to old problems?"

NZ Herald: "Student Volunteer Army to auction playhouse"

Volunteering Australia: "State of Volunteering in Australia 2012"

Weaving Connections - Tuhonohono rangatahi: "Positive Youth Development"

The Telegraph: "Volunteering legacy will help students find jobs"

Management4Volunteers Blog: "The By-Products of Volunteering"

The Times: "Volunteering is great experience"

World Volunteer Web: "Benefits of volunteering"

The Guardian: "So you want to work in the voluntary sector?"

The Guardian: "Youth volunteering portal launched"

vInspired



Negative impact highlighted

Lattitude Global Volunteering: "Avoiding the dangers of 'voluntourism'"

Sydney Morning Herald: "It was a dream job for her"

Management4Volunteers Blog: "Breaking Bounds"

Children and Youth Speak for Themselves

Blue Avocado: "Court-Ordered Community Service: Volunteers or Prison Labor?"

Stanford Social Innovation Review: "The New Volunteer Workforce"

eHow: "Disadvantages of Volunteer Work"

eHow: "Pros & Cons of Mandatory Community Service Projects Before Graduation From High School"

Good Intentions Are Not Enough

The Chronicle of Philanthropy: "The Dirty Truth About Disaster Fundraising"

The Telegraph: "Orphanage tourism: help or hindrance?"

Management4Volunteers Blog: "The Totally Bad Volunteer Experience"

Peter Levine: "the promise and perils of volunteering"

How Stuff Works: "How Volunteer Burnout Works"